Skip to content

video locked to private due to unverified API project #86

Open

Description

@Masiromem

We submitted that the video was uploaded using a third party tool that failed our verification. Because of this, we set limited access for the video.

Activity

  1. Jaom commented on Aug 24, 2020

    @Jaom

    At which step did you encounter this message?
    Perhaps this message is not about the program youtubeuploader itself or "My application in Google Cloud Console" program?

    youtubeuploader seems to be still working for me, although I've been asking for increased quota (and was eventually granted) which means that I'm already audited. Nevertheless I was able to successfully upload several videos making them unlisted or private (I didn't feel like uploading a public video to notify my subscribers).

  2. Masiromem commented on Aug 24, 2020

    @Masiromem
    Author

    I have been using youtubeupload for a month now, everything was fine. For about a week I have been uploading videos to several accounts, as soon as I make the video public, I immediately block it. Tested on Windows 7 and Ubuntu 18.04

  3. Jaom commented on Aug 24, 2020

    @Jaom

    I've just uploaded this video using youtubeuploader: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1IXTedsbp0
    As for now it's public with no problems (forgive the quality of my gameplay).

    The command I've used was:
    youtubeuploader -filename League\ of\ Legends\ 2020.07.04\ -\ 10.58.21.04.mp4 -secrets client_secret.json -headlessAuth

  4. Shaun-64 commented on Aug 25, 2020

    @Shaun-64

    I think I'm having this same problem. Used this program for the first time yesterday, and the video gets locked to private shortly after upload due to using an unverified third party service. Here's an image of the notification email from youtube.

    Seems related to this recent change, requiring all youtube API projects made after July 28th undergo an audit before allowing normal uploads.

    I'm very inexperienced with all this though, so I may well have simply set something up wrong!

  5. danguyf commented on Aug 25, 2020

    @danguyf

    I came here to report this as well. I was having no issue using youtubeuploader until last night. I uploaded a video and it was locked to private minutes later, so I deleted it and uploaded another video as a test and the same thing happened.

  6. Jaom commented on Aug 25, 2020

    @Jaom

    Here's an image of the notification email from youtube.

    This seems to straighten my case that the API key / usage is unverified rather than youtubeuploader itself. I had na audit before (due to asking for increased quota) and I don't have this issue.

    This is very sad as going through the audit is rather tedious as the process is designed for applications open to the public which is the dominant case from API usage perspective but a rare case as I imagine for every big and popular app there are dozens or hundreds of "private" use cases.

  7. porjo commented on Aug 25, 2020

    @porjo
    Owner

    Thanks for the report, I was unaware of this issue. It does sound like bad news for youtubeuploader - yet another hurdle to overcome.

    From Google's announcement:

    All videos uploaded via the videos.insert endpoint from unverified API projects created after 28 July 2020 will be restricted to private viewing mode. To lift this restriction, each project must undergo an audit to verify compliance with the Terms of Service.

    Creators who use an unverified API client to upload video will receive an email explaining that their video is locked as private, and that they can avoid the restriction by using an official or audited client.

    API projects created prior to 28 July 2020 are not currently affected by this change. However, we strongly recommend that all developers complete a compliance audit for their projects to ensure continued access to the YouTube API Services.

    Just to confirm, the videos are locked to private (i.e. they can't be manually changed to public after upload) ?

  8. changed the title [-]Youtube remove video youtubeuploader[/-] [+]video to be locked to private due to unverified API project[/+] on Aug 25, 2020
  9. changed the title [-]video to be locked to private due to unverified API project[/-] [+]video locked to private due to unverified API project[/+] on Aug 25, 2020
  10. Shaun-64 commented on Aug 25, 2020

    @Shaun-64

    Just to confirm, the videos are locked to private (i.e. they can't be manually changed to public after upload) ?

    Can confirm, video is locked to private and can't be changed to public.

  11. danguyf commented on Aug 26, 2020

    @danguyf

    I am just looking to upload a few videos a week. Are there any existing, verified API "projects" that I can use or am I stuck getting my own verified for such a small scale use?

  12. ridvansan commented on Aug 29, 2020

    @ridvansan

    I have this problem either. I taught this was my program's error etc. Until we start the confirmation process may I use someone's API (I need just client_secrets.json). We will upload maximum 1-2 video per day.

  13. Slavko-P commented on Sep 2, 2020

    @Slavko-P
    Contributor

    API's are used to simplify development, but sadly Google/Youtube didn't get that note. Maybe the API should be replaced with Selenium. One project does a similar thing: https://github.com/linouk23/youtube_uploader_selenium But it isn't really practical for automation yet.

  14. jorisr21 commented on Sep 3, 2020

    @jorisr21
    Contributor

    Selenium has no relevance to this issue. I further don't think selenium would offer much benefit because web browser interaction is very very minimal. And it would be a dependency on a huge package.

  15. 33 remaining items

  16. ravener commented on Aug 2, 2023

    @ravener

    just got mine approved, took me like 14 days but I also missed providing some information that caused some delays so realistically it was like 7 days.

    At first I had no hope since the form looked so intimitading and I felt like I filled it so unprofessionally but it still got the point across, I just clearly mentioned that it's not a business/service and strictly for personal use and even linked to this tool's repository.

    So if anyone else is afraid of the form, fret not they'll take it really easy on you if you make the purpose clear.

  17. Supded commented on Aug 10, 2023

    @Supded

    just got mine approved, took me like 14 days but I also missed providing some information that caused some delays so realistically it was like 7 days.

    At first I had no hope since the form looked so intimitading and I felt like I filled it so unprofessionally but it still got the point across, I just clearly mentioned that it's not a business/service and strictly for personal use and even linked to this tool's repository.

    So if anyone else is afraid of the form, fret not they'll take it really easy on you if you make the purpose clear.

    How did you provide additional information to them? Just reply to email? I have the same situation.

  18. ravener commented on Aug 11, 2023

    @ravener

    @Supded yes, once you get an email everything is followed up in there so you just reply to anything asked.

  19. Supded commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @Supded

    @Supded yes, once you get an email everything is followed up in there so you just reply to anything asked.

    It works, thanks!

  20. ErinPo commented on Sep 4, 2023

    @ErinPo

    @Supded yes, once you get an email everything is followed up in there so you just reply to anything asked.

    Did getting your uploader audited cause previously uploaded videos to become unlocked or only new uploads are unlocked?

  21. ravener commented on Sep 5, 2023

    @ravener

    @ErinPo

    Did getting your uploader audited cause previously uploaded videos to become unlocked or only new uploads are unlocked?

    Only new uploads are unlocked, you should re-upload previously uploaded videos.

  22. hellishvictor commented on Oct 9, 2023

    @hellishvictor

    Same thing here: image

    Same here; if I just delete that video and upload it again with the browser, not problems at all.

  23. mixpc commented on Jan 4, 2024

    @mixpc

    Could anyone, please, that has already passed the audit, be kind enough to report what checkboxes were selected, what sort of text input? I am really having a hard time trying to figure out what to select or type, when all I need is just very short (less than one minute) videos be uploaded.
    eg. Does this API Client display data from, or provide features or services across, multiple platforms (e.g. Facebook, Twitter, etc.)? *
    I think not but who knows! This form is frustrating. Thank you!

  24. jorisr21 commented on Jan 5, 2024

    @jorisr21
    Contributor

    I don't remember all the questions from the form, but whatever you fill in, the people from the audit team normally ask some questions afterwards. They focus on web applications, interactive web sites, and hardly understand that you are using a command line application, it appears. You have to mentioning this explicitly. They are concerned about the security aspects, but that is no issue with this application. So I think it works to explain that it's not running on a web server, there is a single user that's using the application, that the user is authenticated when he logs into the PC, that there is no data from google being stored or exported elsewhere, and there is no other automatic connection with other systems.

  25. grnqrtr commented on Jan 5, 2024

    @grnqrtr

    @mixpc I don't remember exactly what I wrote in all the fields, but like @jorisrobijn said, just explain simply what you are trying to do. In fields that didn't apply I would just write something like, "I don't believe this applies to my use case. I merely want to be able to upload videos via a command line interface for one user (me)."

    If a field required so many characters, I would copy and paste something like this several times: "This field requires at least 200 characters so I am copying and pasting this sentence several times just to fulfill the requirement."

    I just explained simply what I was trying to do and passed the audit pretty easily and fairly quickly.

  26. mixpc commented on Jan 5, 2024

    @mixpc

    @jorisrobijn @grnqrtr Thank you for your feedback, appreciated. And thank you for the link to the form. Request submitted! I'll revert - fingers crossed! @porjo tried two or three apps to upload videos to YouTube in the past and either they were outdated or run successfully every now and then... Yours, superb! 🔝 Only miss uploading to a given channel, but I've seen that's already being managed in a different topic. Thank you! ⭐

  27. mixpc commented on Jan 8, 2024

    @mixpc

    Ok, I've been asked to report back about my use case:

    Please confirm if you are requesting for additional quota allocation, if so, please let us know how much it be.

    The reason for completing the YouTube API form was "I am completing a compliance audit or requesting additional API quota".

    So by their feedback I understand compliance audit is not an option but I should request additional API quota. Is that right? And also, how much it be? How should I know? Are they referring to how many MB on average per video file?

    Thank you!

  28. qwelias commented on Feb 15, 2024

    @qwelias

    So do I need to just request quota or do I also need to publich/verify the app?

  29. Sc0ttmeup commented on Jun 30, 2025

    @Sc0ttmeup

    I'm waiting on an audit since May of this year.

    Is it normal for approval to take this long?

    I asked for an update and was told basically to keep waiting.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions

      ⌂ 换网址